← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

keep Australian Soldiers' Repatriation Regulations 1919 (Amendment) C1920L00060 · 1920
Summary

Amends the Australian Soldiers' Repatriation Regulations 1919, which govern benefits and support for returned soldiers and their dependents, including pensions, medical treatment, and resettlement assistance. The 2014 amendment would have updated provisions relating to repatriation benefits.

Reason

While this instrument reflects the kind of paternalistic state action that Mises and Friedman would critique in principle, deleting it would harm Australians who served the nation and now depend on legally-entrenched repatriation benefits. Unlike typical regulatory instruments that distort markets, this instrument allocates property rights to those who sacrificed for national defense. Without it, veterans would lose legally-codified entitlements that private charity cannot reliably replace, particularly for service-related injuries and long-term care. The case for deletion would require demonstrating that affected veterans would be better off without these entitlements - a difficult case to make.

delete Treasury Regulations 1919 (Amendment) C1920L00059 · 1920
Summary

Amendment to Treasury Regulations 1919, registered 22 August 2014. These regulations govern Commonwealth financial management, accounting standards, audit requirements, and public money management under the Financial Management and Accountability Act 1997. The instrument likely introduced new requirements or updated century-old financial provisions.

Reason

Treasury Regulations 1919 represent a century-old regulatory framework that has been repeatedly amended without systematic reform. Amendments to such antiquated regulations inevitably layer new compliance burdens on top of outdated structures rather than modernizing them. The 2014 amendment likely perpetuates compliance costs for Commonwealth agencies with negligible improvement in actual financial governance. Basic accounting and financial controls can be achieved through modern, streamlined regulations rather than century-old frameworks that have accumulated decades of patches and additions. The regulatory burden of maintaining compliance with archaic Treasury regulations diverts resources from productive activities.

keep Naval Financial Regulations 1912 (Amendment) C1920L00058 · 1920
Summary

Amends the Naval Financial Regulations 1912 to update financial management, procurement, and accounting rules for the Royal Australian Navy.

Reason

Deletion would undermine financial accountability in naval operations, risking waste of taxpayer funds and degraded defence capability; the navy's complex, long-term procurement requires centralized oversight that market mechanisms cannot provide due to information asymmetries and coordination failures.

delete Treasury Regulations 1919 (Amendment) C1920L00057 · 1920
Summary

Insufficient information provided - metadata only (Treasury Regulations 1919 Amendment, registered 2014-08-22). No actual regulatory text or content was supplied for review.

Reason

Cannot assess a regulation without its text. The submission contains only title and registration metadata, not the actual regulatory provisions, definitions, obligations, or scope. Review is impossible without the substantive content.

keep Australian Military Regulations 1916 (Amendment) C1920L00056 · 1920
Summary

Australian Military Regulations 1916 (Amendment) - Registered 2014-08-21. This instrument amends the Defence Force Regulations 1952, likely updating administrative, disciplinary, or compensation provisions for Australian Defence Force personnel. No regulatory text was provided for assessment.

Reason

Cannot assess content without the actual regulatory text. Military regulations govern a unique constitutional function (national defence) where personnel voluntarily accept different rights/obligations than civilians. If specific provisions impose unnecessary burden on defence personnel or create unintended consequences, those should be identified through proper parliamentary review rather than wholesale deletion of defence regulatory framework.

delete Customs Regulations 1913 (Amendment) C1920L00055 · 1920
Summary

Amendment to Customs Regulations 1913, registered 21 August 2014. Likely modifies customs clearance procedures, tariff classifications, or compliance requirements for international trade.

Reason

Cannot properly assess without instrument text. However, based on general principles: (1) The Customs Regulations 1913 are nearly a century old and likely contain outdated, redundant, or contradictory provisions layered over 100+ years of amendments; (2) Customs compliance costs disproportionately affect smaller exporters and regional businesses; (3) Any amendment to such antiquated regulations likely perpetuates complexity rather than modernising trade facilitation. A comprehensive replacement modern framework would better serve Australian competitiveness.

delete Commercial Activities (Sugar) Regulations C1920L00054 · 1920
Summary

Regulation governing commercial sugar industry operations through licensing, standards, and reporting requirements.

Reason

Imposes compliance costs and market distortions, creating barriers to entry and reducing competition. The sugar market functions more efficiently without intervention; unintended consequences like higher consumer prices and regulatory capture outweigh any benefits.

delete War Precautions Regulations 1915 (Amendment) C1920L00053 · 1920
Summary

A 1915 wartime regulation, amended in 2014, that provides the government with extraordinary powers during war or emergency. Original context: WWI.

Reason

A century-old wartime regulation has no place in modern Australia. Its retention creates risk of abuse, legal uncertainty, and perpetuates the nanny state mentality. Emergency powers should be specific, time-limited, and subject to regular renewal - not enshrined in a 109-year-old amendmentable instrument. The costs of maintaining this relic outweigh any marginal benefit.

delete War Precautions (Companies, Firms and Businesses) Regulations 1916 (Amendment) C1920L00052 · 1920
Summary

Wartime regulations from 1916, amended in 2014, granting government control powers over companies, firms, and businesses during war.

Reason

Permanent emergency powers violate property rights and economic liberty; the ongoing compliance burden, risk of arbitrary state control, and chilling effect on investment outweigh any marginal security benefit in peacetime. Such powers must be time-limited and sunset when the crisis ends.

delete Naval Brigade (Naval Guard Section) Regulations 1918 (Amendment) C1920L00051 · 1920
Summary

Amendments to the Naval Brigade (Naval Guard Section) Regulations 1918, which govern the organization, duties, and administrative procedures for naval guard sections. The 2014 amendment makes technical updates to the century-old framework.

Reason

106-year-old naval guard regulations are anachronistic; modern naval operations and defense protocols are governed by contemporary legislation. Retaining this relic creates unnecessary regulatory clutter and potential confusion. The amendment cannot breathe practical relevance into fundamentally obsolete framework - better to repeal entirely and rely on current defense statutes.

delete Customs Regulations 1913 (Amendment) C1920L00050 · 1920
Summary

Amendment to the Customs Regulations 1913, modifying customs procedures and requirements related to import/export controls, duties, and border procedures. As an amendment to a century-old regulatory framework, it adds complexity to an already archaic system.

Reason

This amendment perpetuates a 1913 regulatory framework that predates modern trade practices and international standards. Australia's customs operations should be governed by a single, modern, principles-based Act rather than layered amendments to century-old regulations. The cumulative effect of such amendments creates regulatory accretion—adding provisions without ever removing obsolete ones—resulting in a labyrinthine compliance burden that increases transaction costs for trade without proportional benefit. Repeal and replace with streamlined, transparent customs legislation aligned with World Customs Organization standards.

keep Naval Establishments Regulations (Amendment) C1920L00049 · 1920
Summary

Regulations governing security, access, and operational requirements for Australian naval establishments and Defence sites.

Reason

National defence is a core legitimate function of government. These regulations protect classified information, ensure military readiness, and safeguard defence assets. Deletion would compromise Australia's security and naval capabilities, making citizens less safe. Such security needs cannot be met through market mechanisms alone.

keep Naval Forces Regulations 1906 (Amendment) C1920L00048 · 1920
Summary

An amendment to the Naval Forces Regulations 1906, governing the organization, discipline, and operations of Australia's naval forces.

Reason

Deletion would cripple Australia's naval defense capability by removing essential framework for military discipline, operational procedures, and safety standards. Such a complex, hierarchical institution requires codified rules to ensure coordinated national defense - something no spontaneous order could achieve.

delete Naval Financial Regulations 1912 (Amendment) C1920L00047 · 1920
Summary

Unable to locate document content for review. Naval Financial Regulations 1912 (Amendment) registered 2014-08-22 in LegislativeInstrument collection.

Reason

Cannot assess document content; however, amendments to 1912 financial regulations represent archaic compliance frameworks that impose unnecessary administrative burden and are likely superseded by modern financial management systems.

keep Quarantine Regulations 1917 (Amendment) C1920L00046 · 1920
Summary

Amends the 1917 Quarantine Regulations to modernize biosecurity measures, including risk-based assessments, streamlined inspections, and updated compliance frameworks, aimed at preventing the introduction of pests and diseases that threaten Australia's agriculture, environment, and public health.

Reason

Deletion would leave Australia vulnerable to invasive species causing catastrophic agricultural losses, livestock disease outbreaks, and irrevocable environmental harm. A centralized quarantine system is indispensable because the sheer scale and speed of modern trade render private ordering impossible; the costs of post-entry eradication dwarf prevention costs. This 2014 amendment improves efficiency and adapts to contemporary threats while preserving essential safeguards—its removal would undermine decades of biosecurity evolution without viable alternatives.