delete Honey Levy (Amount of Levy) (No. 1) Regulations
Imposes a compulsory levy of $0.026 per kilogram on Australian honey producers (those producing >5 tonnes annually) to fund the Honey Bee Industry Council's activities including marketing, research, and biosecurity. Requires monthly returns, payment within 28 days, and imposes penalties for non-compliance.
This compulsory levy violates the principle that wealth is created by liberty, not decree. Honey producers are forced to fund industry activities regardless of whether they benefit from them, creating a wealth transfer from producers to the Council. Biosecurity should be funded through general taxation (a public good), while marketing and R&D should emerge voluntarily through private cooperatives or industry associations that demonstrate value. The administrative burden of returns, record-keeping, and compliance falls disproportionately on small-to-medium operations. The levy also creates moral hazard: the Council faces little accountability for results since funding is guaranteed by law. Market-based coordination through voluntary memberships and competitive service provision would achieve the same goals without compulsion, allowing producers to choose how to allocate their capital based on actual returns rather than bureaucratic edict.